Are collies like me really among the cleverest dogs?

The short answerIn the most famous ranking, the Border Collie came first and the rough collie about sixteenth. That list only measured how quickly dogs learn and obey commands, and newer research finds breed tells you less about a dog's cleverness than people think.

The longer story

The ranking comes from a 1994 book by the psychologist Stanley Coren, who asked 199 obedience judges to rate breeds on how fast they learned new commands and how reliably they obeyed. The Border Collie came first and the Shetland sheepdog sixth. The collie tied for sixteenth place, in the group of "excellent working dogs" that learn a new command in 5 to 15 tries.

The ranking measures obedience and nothing else. Later studies tested other kinds of cleverness, such as memory, self-control and solving puzzles, and found that breeds can be good at one and ordinary at another. A study of more than 18,000 dogs found that breed explains only a small part of how an individual dog behaves.

When people say collies are the cleverest dogs, they usually mean Border Collies, a different breed from me. The famous dog Chaser, who learned the names of 1,022 toys, was a Border Collie.

Ashley sits beside a big heap of soft toys on the living room rug, watching a black and white Border Collie beside her pick one toy out of the heap in its mouth.
A black and white Border Collie stands in front of a row of five toys on the floor and noses the one toy that is new and different from the others.
Did you know?

Chaser could work out the name of a toy she had never seen by ignoring all the ones she already knew.

Still a mystery

How much of a dog's cleverness comes from its breed and how much from the dog itself.

Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.

@ashleyandstaff