Does sniffing tire me out?

The short answerNobody really knows. Twenty minutes of sniffing is said to be worth an hour's walk, but nobody seems to have measured it. A dog's heart beats faster on a sniffing search than on a plain walk, so sniffing seems to get me going.
The longer story
You may have heard that twenty minutes of sniffing tires a dog as much as an hour's walk. It's a lovely idea, and I'd happily help test it, but nobody seems to have. Three big UK dog charities don't say it either. Dogs Trust does say that sniffing is natural and that dogs should be allowed to do it on walks.
Scientists in one study put heart monitors on 21 pet dogs. Each dog did a short search for a smell and a short walk round a quiet room. Their hearts beat faster during both, and fastest during the search. The dogs held their tails higher while searching and showed no signs of stress, so the scientists think a search gets a dog going. Nobody checked whether the dogs were tired afterwards.
Does sniffing make dogs happier? In one small study, dogs given daily sniffing games seemed more optimistic afterwards. Another found that sniffing classes did no better than obedience classes.
So I'll keep sniffing for the simplest reason of all. I enjoy it.


Big or small, dogs take about four to seven sniffs a second, roughly as fast as a dog pants.
Nobody knows yet whether sniffing tires a dog out or helps them sleep, how it compares with a walk, or what it does for puppies.
Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.
@ashleyandstaff