Do dogs feel guilty, or just look it?

The short answerWe look guilty, certainly. But experiments show the look appears when you sound cross, whether or not we did anything. So the look tells you about your voice, and nothing at all about the sofa cushion.
The longer story
In 2009 a scientist in New York filmed 14 dogs who had been told not to eat a treat while their owners left the room. Sometimes the dog ate it and sometimes it did not. Then owners were told, often wrongly, whether their dog had eaten it. The guilty look depended on whether the owner scolded, and it was strongest in dogs who had obeyed and were told off anyway.
A Hungarian study found the same: dogs who had eaten the food did not look any guiltier than dogs who had not. A study of 96 owners and dogs in Croatia, where owners did not scold, found owners could not tell from their dog's behaviour whether it had done anything wrong.
Most scientists think the look is a way of calming an owner who seems angry. In a survey, nearly 60 in every 100 owners said the look made them scold less, which from where I sit sounds like a result.


Dogs who had done nothing wrong but were scolded looked guiltier than dogs who had really eaten the treat.
Whether dogs feel anything like guilt at all. The experiments show that the look does not prove a dog did wrong. They cannot show what the dog feels.
Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.
@ashleyandstaff