Why does a growing collie need just the right amount of calcium?

The short answerBecause too much calcium can harm the growing bones of big puppies, and so can too little. Complete puppy foods are made to set levels of calcium, so don't add a supplement unless your vet says so.

The longer story

Calcium builds bones, so you'd think more is better. For a big puppy, it isn't. Until about six months old, a puppy's gut takes in calcium whether the puppy needs it or not, so more in the bowl means more in the body. In big puppies, too much calcium harms the way bones grow, and the balance of calcium and phosphorus matters as well as the amount. That's why foods for large-breed puppies have a strict limit on calcium, and why vets say adding supplements to a complete food can do harm.

Too little is bad too. Home-made recipes often get calcium wrong, and one big puppy fed an unbalanced home-made diet ended up with fractures.

Most of what's known comes from Great Dane puppies, and scientists still argue about whether the harm lasts into adult life.

So where does a collie fit? Feeding guides draw the line for a "large breed" in different places, and none of them mentions collies. The Royal Kennel Club puts the rough collie in its large group. I'm a big dog in the making and my food matters, so my staff ask the vet and the breeder.

Ashley lopes across the garden lawn in a natural, easy run, one front paw reaching forward and her back paws pushing off the grass, her legs straight and strong and her ears up. She is alone in the garden: no people, no legs and no feet anywhere in the picture.
A tricolour rough collie puppy standing side on, with long straight legs.
Did you know?

Great Dane puppies grew much faster than Miniature Poodles on the same food, and their growing bones were less even.

Still a mystery

Nobody knows yet how far the Great Dane findings apply to a rough collie, or whether too much calcium as a puppy still matters when the dog is grown up.

Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.

@ashleyandstaff