Give it to me

AshleyWhat I'm holding is mine, and I'm holding it because it's the best thing in the room. A hand that reaches for it only confirms its value. Something better held at my nose is another matter, because I open my mouth to consider the offer, and the toy comes back to me afterwards.

How to teach a puppy to drop what they are holding when you ask

  1. Step 1

    Offer a plain toy

    Give your puppy a toy they like but are not wildly excited by, and let them play with it for a few seconds.

    Ashley stands alone on the rug with the middle of the rope toy in her mouth and both of its knotted ends swinging free on either side of her head.
  2. Step 2

    Hold out a treat

    Hold a very tasty treat at your puppy's nose. When they drop the toy, say "yes", so they know what earned the treat, and give it to them.

    A hand holds a treat at Ashley's nose, and the rope toy drops from her mouth to the floor.
  3. Step 3

    Give the toy back

    While your puppy eats, pick up the toy. Give it back to them soon after.

    A hand holds the rope toy out to Ashley, and Ashley takes it.
  4. Step 4

    Say "drop it"

    Once your puppy drops the toy as soon as they see the treat, say "drop it" as they let go. After several tries, say the word without showing the treat, and reward the drop.

    The rope toy lies on the floor at Ashley's paws, and Ashley looks up at an empty open hand.
  5. Step 5

    Swap for something better

    When you need to take something from your puppy, such as a shoe, swap it for something as good or better. If the thing is not dangerous, you can also wait until they lose interest and drop it.

    Ashley holds a shoe in her mouth beside the row of shoes, and a hand offers her a treat.
Good to know

Ashley: When you swap and then give my toy back, I learn that letting go costs me nothing, so I let go more easily the next time.

If that doesn't work

Ashley: If I'm holding something dangerous, look away, scatter treats in another room and pick the thing up while I'm busy. If I guard my things, ask the vet and a qualified trainer for help before you go on.

Never do this

Ashley: Never prise my mouth open, fight me for what I'm holding, chase me or keep taking things away from me.

Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.

@ashleyandstaff