Taking treats gently

AshleyA treat in a hand is still a treat, and my instinct is to collect it at speed, along with whichever fingers are holding it. A hand that stays shut until I have composed myself has changed my view, because sitting back opens it faster than teeth do.
How to teach a puppy to take treats gently
- Step 1
Close your fist
Sit on the floor with treats in your closed fist on your knee, and say nothing while your puppy sniffs. If they nibble or paw hard, hide your hand behind your back for 5 seconds.

- Step 2
Open your hand
When your puppy backs away, looks away or stops pawing, open your hand to show the treats. Close it if they move towards it and open it when they back away, until they stop going for the open hand.

- Step 3
Hold out one treat
Hold one treat about 20 centimetres from your puppy's nose. If they lean in, put it back in your palm at once, and once they wait, place it in their mouth.

- Step 4
Say "gentle" each time
After three or four treats placed calmly in your puppy's mouth, say "gentle" each time you place the next one.

- Step 5
Keep your hand low
Always offer treats at or below the height of your puppy's muzzle.

Good to knowAshley: Small, moist treats suit me best, because a large one sticks to your hand and I have to work to get it off.
If that doesn't workAshley: Go back to the step before whenever I move towards the treat, and don't hurry me if I'm nervous. If nothing improves, or I seem frightened or angry around food, speak to the vet first.
Never do thisAshley: Never hold a treat above my head, jerk your hand away or tell me off for grabbing.
Ashley & Staff · a tricolour collie puppy and the staff she is trainingashleyandstaff.com/learning/taking-treats-gently/
Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.
@ashleyandstaff