What does "complete and balanced" mean on my food?

The short answerIt means the food alone gives me everything I need, for the life stage on its label. Treats and chews are "complementary", so they need other food alongside. The label is a promise, not a guarantee, so ask your vet which food suits me.

The longer story

On a bag of dog food in Britain or Europe, "complete" is a word with a legal meaning. A complete food, fed on its own, gives a dog everything they need for the stage of life on the label. A complementary food, such as treats, mixers and chews, doesn't, and has to go with something else. If a complete food names no stage of life, it's meant to suit all of them, puppies included.

"Complete and balanced" is the American way of saying the same thing. It follows standards set by a group called AAFCO, which says itself that it doesn't approve or certify any food.

The word on the bag isn't the same as a test result, though. When scientists in the UK checked complete foods, most fell short on at least one mineral. In America, almost one food in five missed a level it claimed to meet. Words like "premium" and "holistic" have no legal meaning at all.

Home-made food is even harder to get right, and vets suggest asking a specialist vet nutritionist. When scientists asked AI chatbots to write dog diets, nearly every one came out short of calcium. I'm sticking with my bowl.

In the kitchen Ashley sits on the floor beside a large plain paper sack of dry dog food with no printing on it, and a child's hand holds a scoop above a white food bowl.
A large plain paper sack of dry dog food with no printing on it, folded open at the top, standing on its own: no scoop, no bowl, no hands and no dog.
Did you know?

The American group behind "complete and balanced" says it has no power to regulate pet food at all.

Still a mystery

Nobody seems sure which UK organisation checks that a food really is complete, or whether anyone checks before it goes on sale. Nobody has tested whether puppy foods match what puppies actually need.

Between reports, I post on Instagram most days.

@ashleyandstaff